SpectrumMagic wrote: ↑

December 14th, 2019, 8:58 pm

Couldn’t watch game could only listen. Why did Anderson only get credit for 2 on his shot early in the game? Was the BYU shot to go up 4 really a three? On radio Scotty made it sound like it should be a 2 after review

I was wondering about Anderson's three also?

Officiating didn’t have anything to do with losing this game

Spectaggie wrote: ↑

December 14th, 2019, 9:21 pm

SpectrumMagic wrote: ↑

December 14th, 2019, 8:58 pm

Couldn’t watch game could only listen. Why did Anderson only get credit for 2 on his shot early in the game? Was the BYU shot to go up 4 really a three? On radio Scotty made it sound like it should be a 2 after review

I was wondering about Anderson's three also?

I believe the refs blew that call. Anderson's three was behind the white college line, but in front of the black NBA line. They called it a two. At the end of the game they did the same to the BYU guy's shot and then upon review they realized it was behind the white line and changed it to a three. I'm curious if they missed other threes. I honestly think they were confused by the two lines.

The missed 3 was embarrassing for that crew. With that extra point, the last minute and a half of the game is played a lot differently when it’s tied and only a one possession game. Had a bigger impact than people want to think. Refs were confused on the 3 point line all night.

Spectaggie wrote: ↑

December 14th, 2019, 9:21 pm

SpectrumMagic wrote: ↑

December 14th, 2019, 8:58 pm

Couldn’t watch game could only listen. Why did Anderson only get credit for 2 on his shot early in the game? Was the BYU shot to go up 4 really a three? On radio Scotty made it sound like it should be a 2 after review

I was wondering about Anderson's three also?

Was the shot by Barcello a three to make it 68-64? On radio Scotty said it looked like a two and would change it after review

SpectrumMagic wrote: ↑

December 14th, 2019, 9:36 pm

Spectaggie wrote: ↑

December 14th, 2019, 9:21 pm

SpectrumMagic wrote: ↑

December 14th, 2019, 8:58 pm

Couldn’t watch game could only listen. Why did Anderson only get credit for 2 on his shot early in the game? Was the BYU shot to go up 4 really a three? On radio Scotty made it sound like it should be a 2 after review

I was wondering about Anderson's three also?

Was the shot by Barcello a three to make it 68-64? On radio Scotty said it looked like a two and would change it after review

Yes, it was to put them up 4 with 20+ seconds left. Had it been a 2, it would've been a 1-possession game.

That doesn't make any sense they could have reviewed it later on in the half or even at halftime if it truly was at 3 that that really makes me mad.

Randy McCall is seriously one of the most biased officials. I dont know if it's malicious or if he's incompetent. If anyone is Tim Donaghy in the NCAA it is McCall.

I've consistently had beef with McCall on this board. It's been overwhelmingly consistent that McCall screws us. I'd be interested who called it a 3 versus a 2... but it was clear when they were reviewing the Porter shot that they were reviewing that they had no clue (or were malicious) that the white line was the 3 pt line and not the blue line.

Understand. Was listening to game not watching and on radio they made it sound like would be changed to 2 just wasn’t sure if that was missed by crew or was behind line. Sounds like lines were causing some issues?

Makes no sense that could not change to a 3 - there is no time limit in rules.

Regardless the team has had some rough shooting stretches starting with north Texas and haven’t gotten going. Hopefully can get healthier and Queta knee holds up and team catches fire and plays well rest of the way

bigblue wrote:Logan next year, BYU steak ends.

Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk

It’s gonna be a long shot with Merrill and Queta gone.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I don’t know. BYU loses a lot of production, including Childs, Haws, Toolsen, Nixon, and Seljaas (All seniors.) They will only return Barcello and Lee as starters. Losing Merrill, Porter, Brito, and probably Queta does hurt but on paper we should match up really well against them next year.

espnaggie wrote: ↑

December 14th, 2019, 10:22 pm

I don’t know. BYU loses a lot of production, including Childs, Haws, Toolsen, Nixon, and Seljaas (All seniors.) They will only return Barcello and Lee as starters. Losing Merrill, Porter, Brito, and probably Queta does hurt but on paper we should match up really well against them next year.

I agree it should be a good game. They also return from injury next year Gavin Baxter which I believe was really coming on at the end of last year.

SpectrumMagic wrote: ↑

December 14th, 2019, 9:44 pm

Makes no sense that could not change to a 3 - there is no time limit in rules.

You would have to think there is a time limit for how far back you can go. I know football has the rule of you can only go back one play, the reason teams always try to snap the ball when a close call or no-call goes their way, so the ruling is in the books and can't be reviewed.

espnaggie wrote: ↑

December 14th, 2019, 10:22 pm

I don’t know. BYU loses a lot of production, including Childs, Haws, Toolsen, Nixon, and Seljaas (All seniors.) They will only return Barcello and Lee as starters. Losing Merrill, Porter, Brito, and probably Queta does hurt but on paper we should match up really well against them next year.

Even if we aren't better than them through out the whole year next year, we can be better than them for just one night in the Spectrum. It's alot easier for teams who aren't better overall to be better for a night on their home court in basketball than football. Think us beating Nevada in 2017 as bad as we were through the year. Or our Big West days when we were always the better team overall, but would sometimes lose on the road or at least have close games against teams we blow out when they come to Logan.

GameFAQSAggie wrote: ↑

December 14th, 2019, 10:29 pm

SpectrumMagic wrote: ↑

December 14th, 2019, 9:44 pm

Makes no sense that could not change to a 3 - there is no time limit in rules.

You would have to think there is a time limit for how far back you can go. I know football has the rule of you can only go back one play, the reason teams always try to snap the ball when a close call or no-call goes their way, so the ruling is in the books and can't be reviewed.

There is probably some kind of limit but typically if there is a disagreement between refs they will check it during the next game break. If you have 1 ref that thinks it's a 3 and another that thinks it's a 2 then it should be reviewed. Period. There is no excuse at all for not reviewing it.

ProvoAggie wrote: ↑

December 14th, 2019, 10:46 pm

GameFAQSAggie wrote: ↑

December 14th, 2019, 10:29 pm

SpectrumMagic wrote: ↑

December 14th, 2019, 9:44 pm

Makes no sense that could not change to a 3 - there is no time limit in rules.

You would have to think there is a time limit for how far back you can go. I know football has the rule of you can only go back one play, the reason teams always try to snap the ball when a close call or no-call goes their way, so the ruling is in the books and can't be reviewed.

There is probably some kind of limit but typically if there is a disagreement between refs they will check it during the next game break. If you have 1 ref that thinks it's a 3 and another that thinks it's a 2 then it should be reviewed. Period. There is no excuse at all for not reviewing it.

Completely agree is all you got to do during a timeout is go to the monitor pretty cut abd dry

Sam was trapped/double teamed the entire game. Big load to carry.

I hate losing to BYU period!

bigblue wrote: ↑

December 14th, 2019, 8:00 pm

Logan next year, BYU steak ends.

Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk

BYU steak tastes like .

BYUFAN4LIFE wrote: ↑

December 14th, 2019, 8:18 pm

ThunderAggie wrote: ↑

December 14th, 2019, 8:06 pm

BYUFAN4LIFE wrote: ↑

December 14th, 2019, 7:58 pm

JUST LIKE FOOTBALL (CLAP CLAP CLAP CLAP CLAP)

How about you go back to Provo and get ready for the Sabbath. Pretty sure your white shirt needs ironed.

Oh the irony. BYU fans get the rep as the “self-righteous” fans yet you make a comment like that. I’m all seriousness, you guys have a great team & best of luck the rest of the season!

In all seriousness, is it possible to survive at BYU without reading the BYU Survival Guide?

2004AG wrote: ↑

December 14th, 2019, 9:55 pm

bigblue wrote:Logan next year, BYU steak ends.

Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk

It’s gonna be a long shot with Merrill and Queta gone

Read more carefully. He’s talking about meat

Aggie in Boise wrote:

bigblue wrote: ↑

December 14th, 2019, 8:00 pm

Logan next year, BYU steak ends.

Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk

BYU steak tastes like .

Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk

We are what our won loss record says we are. Would have loved to win that game, but they were the better team last night.

I still love this team

Still got a ton of basketball left. We got embarrassed by a much worse BYU team last year and our season still turned out great. It’s going to feel like a whole different season come February and March.

Still would’ve been nice to beat them tho.

The curse of the bambino ended. The curse of the billy goat ended. Someday the curse of the apology will end too.

Where's putzie's Shoshone buddy?

Aggie formerly in Hawaii wrote: ↑

December 15th, 2019, 1:11 pm

The curse of the bambino ended. The curse of the billy goat ended. Someday the curse of the apology will end too.

So like in 80 or so years?

I wouldn't mind meeting byu again in the post season with the Aggies being heathier. I also think Craig Smith has given other teams the blue print on how to defeat byu with the zone. Just wish USU would have used the zone in the first half.